Directional Hitting

How It Works:
Directional Hitting simplifies the process by MLB The Show 25 Stubs letting you influence swing direction (pull, push, or up the middle) with the left stick while focusing mainly on timing. The PCI moves automatically, based on your hitter’s attributes.

Pros:

Easier for beginners to pick up.

Great for franchise or Road to the Show players.

Removes pressure of precise PCI control.

Cons:

Limited precision compared to Zone.

Harder to control where the ball goes.

Less effective in competitive online play.

Best For:
Players who want a more casual experience, or those focusing on offline modes where ratings matter more than precision.

3. Timing Hitting

How It Works:
Timing Hitting is the most beginner-friendly option. All you do is press swing at the right time—no PCI control at all. The game calculates contact quality based solely on swing timing and player ratings.

Pros:

Very accessible for new players.

Focuses entirely on timing recognition.

No need to worry about analog stick precision.

Cons:

Zero control over contact point.

Highly dependent on RNG (random number generation) and player ratings.

Severely limits growth in buy MLB Stubs competitive play.